Who should be comic-Andrea?

[AlVan]

This is a favorite topic of mine, due to the fact that Andrea is my favorite GN character and TV Andrea was royally fucked up and killed. I go back and forth on who I think would make for the coolest in a sniper scene, but I most often decide on Sasha. Although, I sometimes think Maggie or Carol would be best in that role. So, what d'you think?

[MR. FIXOB]

Sasha

[nonono]

No question. Sasha.

[ROOM 237]

I'm sticking with Maggie-although these rumors I hear lately about her long range survival prospects are deterring me a bit.

[AlVan]

A lot of her traits are already being split, so it's not like they can't keep doing that. I say Sasha would make the best as an all-around incarnation of her, but Maggie can still be the sniper up in the tower, and Carol could take on her softer material. Then again, Carol could also take on her most deadly material as well, considering recent events.

[ROOM 237]

I'm just glad that there are now several STRONG females characters at the show's current juncture. That was an ingredient sorely missing for most of TWD's early history:interesting,likable female characters. Say what you want about Carol-- but she is DEFINITELY more interesting now than Lori or Andrea ever were.

But back on topic between Carol, Maggie, and Sasha, AlVan is right they have kind of spread a little comic book Andrea around amongst all of them. Again a perfect example of why the show does not and should not follow the comics too closely.

[Ahrean (The Goddess)]

Jan 7, 2014 4:01:26 GMT ROOM 237 said:

I'm sticking with Maggie-although these rumors I hear lately about her long range survival prospects are deterring me a bit.

I'm gonna go with Maggie too, I'll stick it out with you my friend. 

[PrimeTolli]

In my mind I feel like carol is becoming the comic version of Andrea. I've stated that before just not here ha. She's becoming total badass. Slowly but surely